Project case study · Pasadena, Texas

Crafting a Stunning Wooden Fence for Jason Deyo in Pasadena, Texas

Jason Deyo wanted a 6-foot cedar privacy fence with a clean, modern look for his Pasadena, Texas property. Here is that job in photos, plus the USDA Forest Products Laboratory facts behind why the fasteners holding a cedar fence together matter as much as the wood, and why sapwood is not the same as heartwood even on the same board.

  • Reviewed Oct 28, 2026
  • Source: USDA Forest Products Lab Wood Handbook
  • 3 job photos
Wood privacy fence with potted plants beside a brick house
The finished cedar privacy fence, Pasadena, Texas.
The short answer

Cedar held up Jason Deyo’s promise of a fence that looks clean and modern for years, but the USDA Forest Products Laboratory’s Wood Handbook is clear that the species alone is not the whole story: the wrong fastener metal can stain cedar black, and a board’s decay resistance depends on whether it is heartwood or sapwood, not just its species.

Very resistantDecay-resistance class of western redcedar heartwood (USDA Wood Handbook, Table 14-1)
Low resistanceWhat untreated sapwood of essentially any species — cedar included — has against decay (Ch.14)
Common defectIron stain from plain carbon steel fasteners on cedar, “even when contractors do the work” (Ch.16)
ASTM A153/AHot-dip galvanizing standard the Handbook names as far less likely than plain steel to stain cedar

Source: USDA Forest Products Laboratory, Wood Handbook: Wood as an Engineering Material, FPL-GTR-282 (2021).

The job: a 6-foot cedar fence with a clean, modern look

Jason Deyo wanted to upgrade the perimeter of his Pasadena, Texas property with a 6-foot-tall cedar privacy fence. He chose cedar for its timeless appearance and its natural resistance to rot and insects, and asked for a clean design that would match the architectural style of his home rather than feel like a plain wall of pickets.

The photos below are from that job.

New wood gate fitted between brick house walls
The matching cedar gate, fitted between the brick walls of the house, Pasadena, Texas.

The fastener choice matters as much as the wood

Cedar’s decay resistance is only half of what decides whether a fence still looks “clean and modern” a few years in. Western redcedar carries high amounts of natural tannin, and the USDA Forest Products Laboratory’s Wood Handbook is direct about what that means for fasteners: “Expect iron stain if using plain carbon steel fasteners on naturally finished exterior wood containing high amounts of tannin, such as western redcedar.” The Handbook adds that this is “common, even when contractors do the work.”

The fix is the metal, not the wood. Stainless steel fasteners are, to the Handbook’s knowledge, safe from iron stain. Where stainless isn’t used, high-quality hot-dip galvanized fasteners meeting ASTM A153/A are far less likely to cause iron stain than plain carbon steel. Pine and other low-tannin woods don’t have this problem the same way — plain steel there just rusts and leaves an ordinary brown stain, not the dark streak cedar produces.

Where above-ground cedar pickets sit in the AWPA use-category system

Use category (USDA Wood Handbook Table 15-6)Service conditionsTypical applications
UC3AExterior construction, above ground, coated and rapid water runoffCoated millwork, siding and trim
UC3BGeneral above-ground use, fully exposed to weatherDecking, fence pickets and rails, guardrail posts
UC4AGeneral ground contact, or above-ground uses that are structurally criticalFence and deck posts, deck beams and supports

USDA Forest Products Laboratory Wood Handbook, Table 15-6 (American Wood Protection Association use-category system). A naturally decay-resistant species like cedar can still be specified against these categories; they describe exposure, not just whether preservative treatment is required.

Two identical cedar boards side by side. The left board has a plain carbon steel nail near the top with a dark black streak bleeding down the board below it. The right board has a stainless or hot-dip galvanized screw near the top with no streak below it. PLAIN CARBON STEEL NAILiron + cedar tannin = black streak (Ch.16) STAINLESS OR HDG SCREWASTM A153/A — no iron stain (Ch.16) Same cedar board, two fastener metals Western redcedar’s own tannins react with plain carbon steel. The Wood Handbook calls the resulting black streak common “even when contractors do the work.”
S-1
DrawingIron stain: the fastener, not the fence
BasisUSDA Wood Handbook Ch.16 (iron stain from plain carbon steel fasteners on high-tannin wood)
ScaleNot to scale
Same board, same species — the streak comes from the fastener metal reacting with the wood’s own tannins, not from a flaw in the cedar.

Heartwood vs. sapwood: not every board performs the same

Cedar’s “very resistant” decay rating describes its heartwood — the darker wood from the center of the tree. The Wood Handbook is equally clear about the lighter wood at the outer edge of the same log: “Untreated sapwood of essentially all species has low resistance to decay.” A board cut mostly from sapwood does not get cedar’s usual decay advantage, regardless of species.

Even heartwood-to-heartwood, performance varies: “Considerable differences in service life can be obtained from pieces of wood cut from the same species, even the same tree, and used under apparently similar conditions.” That’s part of why a visual check of the boards going up — not just the species on the invoice — is worth doing on a privacy fence meant to look clean for years.

Elevation of one cedar board split into three vertical zones: a lighter sapwood strip on each outer edge and a darker heartwood zone in the middle. The heartwood zone is labeled very resistant decay class, Table 14-1. Each sapwood strip is labeled low decay resistance, untreated, any species, Chapter 14. sapwoodheartwoodsapwood LOW decay resistanceuntreated, any species (Ch.14) “Very resistant” decay classwestern redcedar heartwood, Table 14-1 One cedar board, two kinds of wood The species’ decay rating belongs to the heartwood only. “Considerable differences in service life” show up between pieces of the same species, even the same tree (Ch.14).
S-2
DrawingHeartwood vs. sapwood in one board
BasisUSDA Wood Handbook Ch.14 (decay resistance applies to heartwood; untreated sapwood of essentially all species has low resistance)
ScaleNot to scale
The decay-resistance rating on the species label belongs to the heartwood. Sapwood on the same board does not carry it.

Cedar fence fastener & board-grade checklist

Pick the fastener metal and how much sapwood shows on the boards. Based on the USDA Forest Products Laboratory’s own notes on tannin staining and sapwood decay resistance. No prices.

Stain risk
Decay class

Fasteners: USDA Wood Handbook Ch.16 (western redcedar’s tannins react with plain carbon steel; stainless is, to the Handbook’s knowledge, safe from iron stain; ASTM A153/A hot-dip galvanized is far less likely to stain than plain carbon steel). Grade: Ch.14 (untreated sapwood of essentially all species has low decay resistance; the heartwood carries the species rating). A checklist, not a lumber-grading inspection.

New wood fence and gate meeting older fencing at a corner
The new cedar fence meeting the property’s existing fence line, Pasadena, Texas.
★★★★★
Amazing work will go ahead and recommend everyone in friends and family We installed 8ft tall double sided stained cedar wood fence in our backyard, it’s really looks great, installed perfectly nice finishing and cost effective, thanks mustang fencing.
Muqeet Mohammed Abdul · Google review · a year ago
★★★★★
had an excellent experience with mustang fencing From the initial consultation to the final installation, the team was professional, punctual, and attentive to detail. They helped me choose the perfect fence style to match my property and ensured everything was installed with precision. The quality of materials is top-notch, and the fence has completely transformed the look and security of my home. I highly recommend mustang services to anyone looking for reliable and high-quality fencing services!
Abdul Wahab · Google review · a year ago
★★★★★
I recently hired Mustang Fencing Services for a fence installation, and I couldn’t be happier with the results. The team was professional, punctual, and very knowledgeable. They provided a detailed estimate and completed the job on time and within budget. Overall highly recommended Mustang fencing services
shaina lalani · Google review · 2 years ago

Reviews shown word for word from the Mustang Fencing Services Google Business Profile (Galveston), captured 2026-10-26.

Questions we get about this

Why do some cedar fences get black streaks under the nails or screws?
Western redcedar contains high amounts of natural tannin. USDA’s Wood Handbook says to expect iron stain when plain carbon steel fasteners are used in high-tannin wood like cedar—and notes it happens “even when contractors do the work.”
Does stainless steel stop cedar from staining?
To the Wood Handbook’s knowledge, yes—stainless steel fasteners are safe from iron stain. Where stainless isn’t used, hot-dip galvanized fasteners meeting ASTM A153/A are far less likely to stain cedar than plain carbon steel.
Is sapwood as decay-resistant as heartwood on a cedar board?
No. USDA’s Wood Handbook states that untreated sapwood of essentially all species, cedar included, has low resistance to decay. Cedar’s “very resistant” rating (Table 14-1) describes its heartwood.
What AWPA use category applies to above-ground cedar fence pickets?
UC3B in the Wood Handbook’s Table 15-6: general above-ground use, fully exposed to weather, with fence pickets and rails listed as a typical application.
Why might two cedar fences from the same species age differently?
USDA’s Wood Handbook notes that considerable differences in service life can come from pieces of wood cut from the same species—even the same tree—used under similar conditions.

Sources

Checked October 28, 2026. Rules change, so confirm with the City before you build.

  1. USDA Forest Products Laboratory, Wood Handbook: Wood as an Engineering Material, FPL-GTR-282 (2021) — Decay resistance of heartwood vs. sapwood and service-life variability (Ch. 14, Table 14-1); AWPA use-category system (Ch. 15, Table 15-6); iron stain from fasteners on high-tannin wood (Ch. 16).
Free on-site estimate

Planning a wood fence or gate?

We’ll walk the property, talk through wood choice, fastening and finishing, and put it on a written quote.

Page reviewed October 28, 2026 by Mustang Fencing Services, Galveston. Next review due April 2027.